Writinghood > Online Writing

Whose Idea Have You Stolen?

Ideas are not protected by copyright. A writer can write about any subject, but stealing other people's ideas does not benefit the writer in the long run.

Finding original ideas for articles is not easy. I write about a whole range of different subjects and try to be original in my subject matter. Like many of you, I may have an original idea and it may do well on Triond.

Then the ‘idea copiers’ start work. They see someone else’s idea and think, ‘Yea, I could write an article about that. I’ll just grab twenty pictures and write a line or two underneath them and I’ll do well’. What actually happens is the social bookmarking sites soon get saturated with articles about the same thing and the idea is no longer original. Everybody loses in the long run as no one bothers to read them anymore.

Many writers are also unaware that search engines like Google and Yahoo need at least 400 words of text so that their robots can scan your article and catalogue it. An article consisting of pictures and hardly any text is difficult for them to log and may be rejected because of that. If you aren’t in the search engine listings you may as well give up once your friends have read your article.

The internet moves very quickly and what was interesting and original today can be copied in a hundred places by tomorrow. You can’t copyright ideas.

A good example was an original article I did on trees. Within a week there was a whole collection of them on Triond. Icebergs, Fruit, Bats, and Seahorses were good ideas to write about at the time but soon became swallowed up among the dozens of new articles on the same subjects.

Nelson Doyle https://www.triond.com/users/Nelson+Doyle used to compile lists of useful websites and did rather well at it until lots of others jumped on the bandwagon.

Judy Sheldon https://www.triond.com/users/Judy+Sheldon/ wrote some brilliant stuff about spices in the diet. What an original idea, until the idea was copied by many others.

As I said before, ideas cannot be copyrighted. Writers can write about what they wish, even if the subject has been covered before.

However, many people are missing the point. In the short term, if you copy someone else’s idea you may be able to generate a lot of reads between your loyal readers and followers but you will not gain in the long run. Once the search engines get packed with very similar article titles, nobody wins. Anyone searching a particular subject has just too many choices. So, long term, you will get no traffic.

It is to everyone’s advantage for writers to find truly original subject matter to write about. Short term reads are not going to bring you long term earnings. Find a particular angle on an ordinary subject, look at it in a different way, change the perspective and don’t just churn out new versions of old ideas.

I have just gone through the Triond recently published list and I found at the most 3 new ideas. The rest had all been done before. Imagine what the selection in a bookshop would be like if they only kept books on specific subjects. You would expect there to be a range of items for you to browse through, no matter what your interests. Triond needs to do the same.

So, why not stop rehashing old ideas and come up with some really original stuff. If we produce more variety of articles, on more subjects, Triond will be able to expand its advertising revenue and we, the writers will benefit.

11
Liked It
I Like It!
Related Articles
Which One is the Best to Write For? Triond or Helium!  |  Tips for Writing
Comments (15)
#1 by  R J Evans, Dec 1, 2008
Some good points well made!
#2 by  Lucas DiĆ©, Dec 1, 2008
R J Evans seconded.
#3 by  BC Doan, Dec 1, 2008
You've raised some wonderful points!

Many people have taken a part other articles, use the same pictures, and didn't even link to them..But as long as it is published, everyone is happy!
#4 by  Judy Sheldon, Dec 1, 2008
Louie, you are so right. We are not in school with someone handing out topics. This is the real world. We think up our own topics, and unfortunately it does not stop there. Words and pictures are being stolen too with no mention of the author they took them from. When you scour the internet and see paragraphs stolen verbatim from your hard thought out article, it is theft. Thank you so much for touching upon this subject.

Take care and God bless.
#5 by  nobert soloria bermosa, Dec 1, 2008
Interesting points,I just would like to add, one real big problem I have encountered is about soulless people who are copying and pasting articles of Triond writers (and from other publishing sites) on their blogsites and earning money from it instead of the creator of the article because they don't provide the link. so far, I have discovered 3 sites who copy/pasted my articles including those of Chan,Lauren,RJ and a lot more. I have already reported the issue to Triond authority and i am hoping that something concrete can be done to stopped this evil practice of some individuals in the internet.
#6 by  Louie Jerome, Dec 1, 2008
Nobert, I understand what you are saying here and I agree with you but this is a different issue. I am referring here to Triond mermbers stealing ideas from other members instead of thinking up their own. I get so annoyed when I notice some members using the new articles list as a list of topics for themselves to write on.
#7 by  Anne Lyken Garner, Dec 1, 2008
Nice article Louie. I think we all can say that we're a victim of this. I had a popular 'legal uses for ...' series, and within the space of a week, this series had been copied, re-shaped and re-published by someone else - using the same 'legal' title.

I also had an article which did very well called '...hilarious crazy reasons...' (I'm shortening them, because I don't want you to think I'm advertising my work on your page) which was redone with just one word in the title changed. I, even mistook this work for mine, when the title was pointed out to me, and wondered why the body of the piece had all those gramatical and spelling mistakes. I didn't complain, but I wasn't pleased.

Having said this, there was an instant where I had just published an article about which I was very excited. I thought that it was totally original, until I was sent a very vulgar message to say I had copied it.
I didn't even know that this said article was in existance until I searched out the sender of the message and found his article of the same nature.

Sometimes we have the same idea as another person, but will approach it differently. On occasions where stealing is blatant, this is terribly unprofessional.

Thanks for writing this.
#8 by  Johaubannah, Dec 1, 2008
We cannot prevent copying. But I hope they will make their own ideas someday onstead of copying.
#9 by  CA Johnson, Dec 1, 2008
You brought up very good points. People do need to be more original. There's no need to copy off of others.
#10 by  R.B. Parsley, Dec 1, 2008
Louie,
Excellent article! It would be different if these copiers were offering new and/or different facts on the same subject. I have a pet subject, that when researching I found tons of information on. Alot of it I wouldn\'t have known if I didn\'t do my research. Hopefully in the very near future you will know what my pet subject is. I don\'t know what people get out of copying someone elses hard work. I would rather be original. That way I can say, \"Yeah, that was my idea.\" Because sooner or later people are going to find out the idea wasn\'t yours, but someone elses, and thats not going to be very good in the long run. You definitely made a lot of great points here. Again Louie, EXCELLENT ARTICLE!!!!!!!!

Randy
#11 by  Inna Tysoe, Dec 1, 2008
Good points.

Inna
#12 by  Louie Jerome, Dec 2, 2008
Thanks for your support everyone. As for why people copy ideas, I think it's because they think they can make quick money with no effort and unfortunately some of them do, but these lazy people soon get fed up when they realise that they can't get rich writing on the internet. Well, I shouldn't say can't, perhaps I should say that they are too lazy too.

#13 by  C Jordan, Dec 5, 2008
Excellent article Louie. I think that many writers on here are here because they like to come up with an original thought and elaborate upon it. Sadly there are others who simply reshape those ideas without adding anything new.
#14 by  Fegger, Jan 7, 2009
The concept of cut-and-paste makes me cringe; and I would find it hard to believe that a legitimate writer would stoop to such tactics. I can see the possibility or propensity of thematic overlap as a phenomenon that would occur naturally. If ten people were to write a generalistic article about their cat, the inherent behaviors of the beast would dictate certain identical observations...and overlap. In this case, as a pioneer, I would make those assumptions and feed my cat narcotics so that the behaviors would be "naturally" altered and I would, of course have certain observations and insights that the other nine writers couldn't claim. By the way, "yeeechhh" back at ya', babe...and nice bit of writing here!
#15 by  thestickman, Jan 9, 2009
Nicely done. :)
Post Your Comment:
Name:  
Copy the code into this box:  
Post comment with your Triond credentials?
Inside Writinghood

Literature

 /

Online Writing

 /

Style

 /

Writing

 /

Writing Business


Popular Tags
Popular Writers
Powered by
Writinghood
About Us
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
Services
Submit an Article
Advertise with Us
Contact

© 2007 Copyright Stanza Ltd. All Rights Reserved.